Effect of protective helmets on vision and sensory performance

    loading  Checking for direct PDF access through Ovid

Abstract

Objective

The purpose of this study was to determine the effect of protective helmets (i.e., football, lacrosse, and ice hockey helmets) on vision and sensory performance.

Design

Experimental cross-over study.

Setting

Clinical research centre.

Subjects

A convenience sample of 24 healthy college-aged males who played American football (n=14), lacrosse (n=5), or ice hockey (n=5) at a minimum of a high school level.

Intervention

Participants completed vision and sensory performance assessments under two counterbalanced conditions: helmeted and unhelmeted.

Outcome measures

The Senaptec Sensory Station assesses visual clarity (LogMAR), contrast sensitivity (logarithm of contrast sensitivity), depth perception (arcsec), near-far quickness (# cycles complete), target capture (threshold response time), perception span (# correct responses), multiple object tracking (tracking capacity), eye-hand coordination (average response time), go/no go (correct minus incorrect hits), and hand reaction time (average reaction time). The overall helmet effect and helmet-by-sport interactions were assessed.

Results

Participants performed 40.7ms slower on eye-hand coordination (95% Confidence Interval [CI]: −66.64, −14.83; p<0.01) and 3.4 points lower on go/no go (95% CI: 1.56, 5.32; p<0.01) when wearing a helmet. Hockey helmets significantly affected visual clarity (95% CI: −0.3701, −0.0883; p=0.01) and hand reaction time (95% CI: −38.67, −9.73; p<0.01), but football and lacrosse helmets did not.

Conclusions

Vision and sensory performance was negatively impacted by wearing a helmet. This inability to see and respond to visual stimuli could have implications for athlete safety and performance, and should be explored further in other at-risk populations such as youth and female athletes.

Competing interests

Kramer: None.

Competing interests

Wasserman: None.

Competing interests

Teel: None.

Competing interests

Mihalik: Dr. Mihalik has an equity interest in Senaptec LLC

Competing interests

Keywords: Concussion, Injury prevention, Vision, Helmet, Facemask

Related Topics

    loading  Loading Related Articles