Pain, motion and function comparison of two exercise protocols for the rotator cuff and scapular stabilizers in patients with subacromial syndrome

    loading  Checking for direct PDF access through Ovid

Abstract

Study Design:

Randomized clinical trial.

Introduction:

Eccentric exercise (EE) was shown to be an effective treatment in tendinopathies. However, the evidence of its effectiveness in subacromial syndrome (SS) is scarce. Moreover, consensus has not been reached on whether best results for SS are obtained by means of EE with or without pain.

Purpose of the Study:

The purpose of this is to compare the effect on pain, active range of motion (AROM), and shoulder function of an exercise protocol performed with pain <40 mm Visual Analog Scale (VAS) and without pain, in patients with SS.

Methods:

Twenty-two subjects (mean age: 59 years [Q1 = 48.50-Q3 = 70], 54.5% women) were randomized into a not-painful EE group (NPEE; G0: n = 11) and a painful EE group (PEE; G1: n = 11). The intervention lasted 4 weeks. Pain was recorded using VAS; AROM was measured using a goniometer; and shoulder function using the modified Constant-Murley Score (CMS) before and after intervention.

Results:

All dependent variables improved significantly in both groups (P < .05): NPEE VAS median: pretest = 55.0 posttest = 28.0; CMS median: pretest = 36.0 posttest = 65.0. PEE VAS median: pretest = 37.0 posttest = 12.0; CMS median: pretest = 35.0 posttest = 59.0. The comparison between groups showed no significant differences, with small effect size values (VAS = 0.09; CMS = 0.21; AROM = 0.12–0.43).

Discussion:

In contrast to the previous findings, our results suggest that PEE do not add benefit in SS patients compared to NPEE.

Conclusion:

Our results suggest that both interventions are effective in terms of pain, function, and shoulder AROM. Furthermore, PEE does not provide greater benefits. Further studies are needed with long-term follow-up to reinforce these results.

HIGHLIGHTS

Findings

HIGHLIGHTS

Possibly, achieving improvements in pain, active ROM, and shoulder function does not rely on performing the exercise with or without pain, but other factors could be involved.

HIGHLIGHTS

Four weeks of intervention are sufficient to produce statistically significant improvements in these variables.

HIGHLIGHTS

Implications

HIGHLIGHTS

The findings suggest that patients with SS could benefit both with a painful exercise protocol and with a pain-free exercise protocol. This could refocus the clinical practice for such patients. However, more research is needed in order to overcome the limitations of this study.

HIGHLIGHTS

Caution

HIGHLIGHTS

According to the clinical judgment of the authors, future studies with a larger sample size and medium long-term monitoring are needed to confirm the results.

Related Topics

    loading  Loading Related Articles