Clinical Applications of 3D Printing
Two more traditional methods of 3D printing were developed through laser printing technology. The first method uses extrusion, whereby layer upon layer of substrate is placed on the build platform, usually with added energy that can cause melting, fusion, or polymerization. The second method is powder-based and consists of layering of a substrate in powder form, followed by addition of energy to cause polymerization or other chemical processes such as melting, sintering, or crystallization to the desired shape. This process is repeated layer by layer.
Several techniques of 3D printing are used for biomaterials. Selective laser sintering, a powder-based method, can achieve high resolution with materials including ceramics, polymers, and metals. Fused deposition modeling uses wires or filaments of material extruded through a polyjet and melted, then polymerized or fused on the plate build, layer by layer, similar to cake decorating. Metal devices can be 3D printed via direct laser deposition, shaped metal deposition, and electron beam melting. The first two processes leave internal stresses and currently are not suitable for medical applications. However, electron beam melting, an FDA-approved process, is used to make orthopedic devices, such as hip acetabular cups and interbody devices. Advantages include optimization of porous surfaces that can be fused to the entire device, rather than sintered on, as is typically done.
For a typical medical device, an object must be created through 3D printing, most commonly with computed tomography or magnetic resonance imaging through segmentation and isolation of a 3D object such as bone. For a biologic implant, a 3D drawing is made, and the region of interest is segmented, often requiring optimization and conversion to STL (stereolithography) file format. The STL is then printed on the 3D printer and the object created.
Advantages of 3D printing include customizable results, speedy design, low cost, availability in a variety of materials, optimized mechanical properties, and low barriers facilitating performance in Third World countries. Disadvantages include altered mechanical properties compared with general manufacturing techniques, unknown performance in vivo, concerns regarding dimensional accuracy, and unknown sterility of metallic devices, as pores created may not be accessible with a gas autoclave. Long-term data on this process are not yet available.
Potential applications for 3D printing include education and simulation training, prosthetics or orthotics, preoperative planning, design and rapid prototyping, manufacture of instruments customized to patients, custom implants, routine manufacture of medical devices, and tissue-engineering applications.
Medical school curricula are de-emphasizing anatomic dissection, making models increasingly important. McMenamin et al1 created 3D complex anatomy models that act as prosected dissection, are relatively low in cost, and can be based on abnormal or normal patient anatomy. Madrazo et al2 used 3D models to enhance patients’ understanding of their medical condition to guide decision making.
Orthotic devices, such as a scoliosis brace, can be customized. Patients’ dimensions are digitized and a brace is created through a process that allows patients to participate in the design of the brace, leading to greater patient satisfaction and improved compliance.