Cardiogenic shock from acute severe mitral valve regurgitation can cause acute liver failure due to hypoperfusion. Impaired liver glycogenesis can then lead to profound hypoglycemia. The time frame for restoring normoglycemia without neurologic sequelae is not clearly established in humans. Thus, the clinical decision to provide further resuscitation in the setting of extreme hypoglycemia mainly depends on the patient’s overall clinical condition, provider opinion, and/or institutional practice. Here, we report a case where the patient made complete neurologic recovery from extreme hypoglycemia (<5 mg/dL by central laboratory testing) secondary to acute cardiogenic shock and liver failure.