Distinguishing Pneumonia From Pneumonitis to Safely Discontinue Antibiotics*
In this issue of Critical Care Medicine, Lascarrou et al (1) use telescopic plugged catheter (TPC) sampling in patients with aspiration syndrome to assess whether negative cultures can allow for safe discontinuation of antibiotics in mechanically ventilated comatose patients. TPC cultures were positive in 43 (46.7%) and negative in 49 (53.3%) of the 92 included patients. Sixteen (32.7%) of the 49 patients continued antibiotic therapy for other infectious concerns. Of the remaining 33 patients (67.3%), antibiotics were discontinued. A lung infection subsequently developed in only two patients (6%), one of whom had a positive TPC culture on repeat sampling, whereas the other did not have repeat sampling. It may also be possible that the lung infection that developed may have been due to recurrent aspirations. There were no significant differences in clinical, laboratory, or radiographic evidence, mechanical ventilation duration, length of stay, or mortality among the bacterial and nonbacterial aspiration groups. This report is unique in that it reignites the use of TPC in aspiration processes, encourages safe antimicrobial discontinuation in patients with negative TPC cultures, and challenges the recommendations of recent randomized trials that have recommended prophylactic antibiotics in cerebrovascular accident patients to reduce the risk of BAP (2).
Although there are numerous methods available to assist the clinician in diagnosing BAP, many have drawbacks. Microbiologic cultures may be contaminated by the oropharyngeal flora and upper airway, regardless of whether it is obtained via expectoration, orotracheal aspiration, nasotracheal aspiration, or bronchoalveolar lavage (BAL). Although there were no reported consequences of fiberoptic bronchoscopy in this article, bronchoscopy still poses additive risks and may also allow for contaminated secretions to be aspirated from the suction channel. Direct needle transtracheal aspiration is invasive and carries a risk of barotrauma, principally in patients undergoing mechanical ventilation. Biomarkers, including procalcitonin, pepsin, and amylase, have been studied. Serum procalcitonin had a poor diagnostic value in differentiating BAP from aspiration pneumonitis (3). Tracheal aspirate α-amylase concentrations are reportedly moderate and inaccurate in diagnosing microaspiration when compared with tracheal secretion or BAL pepsin, which may potentially be used to suggest aspiration in patients with moderate reflux or abnormal swallow though further evidence is needed (4).
Studies analyzing TPC are scarce and dated to nearly 2 decades ago. Wimberley et al (5) first introduced TPC in 1979 to attain lower airway samples with minimal risk of contamination by avoiding upper airway flora. While blinded introduction of the TPC through an endotracheal tube is possible, most institutions that use TPC sampling perform fiberoptic bronchoscopy. Combining BAL with TPC yields a sensitivity of 88% and specificity of 100% (6).