To evaluate and compare the efficacy of two opioid agonist-antagonists, nalbuphine and butorphanol, in reversing etorphine-induced respiratory depression in immobilized goats.Study design
Prospective, crossover, experimental trial conducted at 1753 m.a.s.l.Animals
Eight adult female Boer goats (Capra hircus).Methods
Eight minutes following immobilization with an intramuscular injection of 0.1 mg kg−1 etorphine, goats were given one of nalbuphine (0.8 mg kg−1), butorphanol (0.1 mg kg−1) or sterile water intravenously, in random order in three trials. Respiratory rate (fR), ventilation, tidal volume, oxygen consumption (SymbolO2) and carbon dioxide production (SymbolCO2) were measured continuously. Arterial blood samples to determine PaO2 and PaCO2 were taken 2 minutes before and at 5 minute intervals after etorphine administration for 25 minutes.Results
Both nalbuphine and butorphanol increased mean PaO2 from 44 mmHg (5.9 kPa) to 63 mmHg (8.4 kPa) after etorphine administration. Butorphanol, but not nalbuphine, also corrected hypopnea and hypoventilation such that fR increased from 13 ± 4 to 21 ± 7 breaths minute−1 (compared with 16 ± 6 breaths minute−1 following nalbuphine) and ventilation increased from 4.69 ± 3.04 to 6.91 ± 4.42 L minute−1 following butorphanol administration. Despite decreases in PaCO2 following nalbuphine and butorphanol, PaCO2 remained elevated compared with pre-immobilization values [nalbuphine: 34 ± 3 mmHg (4.5 ± 0.3 kPa); butorphanol: 34 ± 2 mmHg (4.5 ± 0.3 kPa)] throughout the immobilization. Both agents also decreased the level of immobilization, and increased SymbolO2 and SymbolCO2.Conclusions
Nalbuphine and butorphanol significantly improved respiratory function in immobilized goats, with butorphanol eliciting a greater positive response than nalbuphine. However, both opioid agonist-antagonists partly reversed etorphine-induced immobilization.Clinical relevance
Butorphanol and nalbuphine can be used to improve respiratory parameters in etorphine-immobilized wildlife, with butorphanol being more effective, but unwanted arousal can occur.